What Is Emotional Manipulation?


You’ve been telling him for years how hurtful his behavior is. Literally begging him to stop. It’s like beating your head against a wall. You’ve reached your breaking point. Then he tosses out a question your heart longed to hear from the beginning:

“What can I do to fix this?” 

Right at the end. Right before your feet hit the pavement. Right before you’ve given up.

What now?

Learn about 3 critical aspects of this kind of emotional manipulation:

  • What this question actually means.
  • Why he never asked it before.
  • Ways to respond that won’t lead you right back onto the hamster wheel of death. 

Click to Play:

Do you have a question related to emotional or spiritual abuse that you’d like answered on the Flying Free podcast? Head over HERE!

Listener Shout-Out

Much love to you in your journey of strength and becoming, Not “Less Than”! Thanks for leaving a rating and review on iTunes!

Subscribe and Review in iTunes

Have you subscribed yet to the Flying Free podcast? If not, why not do that today? It’s easy! Click here to subscribe in iTunes!

If you’ve got a few extra seconds, I’d love it if you left us a review over on iTunes, too. Those reviews help other people find this podcast and they’re also fun to read! Just click here to review, select “Ratings and Reviews” and “Write a Review” and let me know what you like best about this podcast. Thank you!

What is Emotional Manipulation? [Transcript]

Hi. This is Natalie Hoffman of Flyingfreenow.com, and you’re listening to the Flying Free Podcast,
a support resource for women of faith looking for hope and healing from hidden emotional and
spiritual abuse.

Welcome to Episode 87 of the Flying Free Podcast!

Today I want to answer a question that I hear all the time:

How do you answer your husband when he says, “Just tell me what I need to do to fix this”?

First of all, you need to know why he is asking that question. And to understand why he’s
asking that question, we need to use an analogy.

Let’s say you are in a room with him, and he is sitting on a chair next to you, kicking you in
the shin every so often. You ask him to stop, and he responds to you by:

• Sometimes ignoring you.
• Sometimes saying, “What’s the big deal? I’m hardly doing anything.
• Sometimes saying, “I’m not kicking you in the shin. Where are you getting that crazy idea
• Sometimes laughing and saying, “You can’t ever take a joke.
• Sometimes yelling at you and saying, “You’re such a nag! What is your problem! You’re on
my case all the time, I can’t do ANYTHING without hearing you gripe and complain!

And the kicking continues for 20 years.

At the end of 20 years, you decide to stand up and leave the room. You say, “I’m sick of you
kicking me in the shin. You don’t think there’s anything wrong with it, so that tells me you’re
going to keep doing it. Since you won’t stop, I’m leaving.”

And his response to you is, “HOW CAN I FIX THIS?’

Do you see it? Now do you see the reason he is asking you that question?

You see, your brain really wants to believe he is asking that question because he genuinely
has no clue that he’s been kicking you. And you would be a nasty old meanie not to tell him
and give. Him a chance. Right? I mean, everyone deserves a chance!

Your brain wants to believe that because it’s been programmed with that thought your
entire life. If someone asks a question – it must be genuine, and you must answer or you’re
being rude.

But is that true? Is that programmed thought always true? In this case it’s not. If you
continue to believe that thought, you’ll feel guilty when you don’t answer and walk away.
When you feel guilty, you’ll overwork, overcompensate, and overeat. You’ll also deny it’s
that bad and minimize the kicks. And you’ll stay in the room with your kicker.

But what if you offered your brain a different thought? What if you thought this instead,
“That’s an interesting question he is asking. Interesting because I’ve told him for 20 years
what’s wrong. And I’m pretty sure he has good hearing and brain tissue. That means his
question isn’t genuine. It’s a challenge to keep me in his little game, and I’m not playing

Now THAT thought causes you to feel clear and empowered. And when you feel clear and
empowered, you say, “I’ve already told you what to do, and then I gave you 20 years to do
it. Good-bye.” And you leave. What is the result in your life? You no longer get kicked in the
shin every day.

I hope that analogy helps a bit. But let’s take it back to real life, because some of you are
thinking, “I still don’t get it. He seems to genuinely want to work on his stuff for the first time
ever! I don’t want to throw away this amazing opportunity if he finally wants to change!”
And you don’t have to. You absolutely don’t have to. But here’s what I suggest you do.

First, find out if he knows what he needs to fix. His programming doesn’t believe he’s done
anything wrong that needs fixing. Because if you think about it, if a bike is broken, would he
ask that question? “What do I need to do to fix this?” He could answer that question all by
himself. “I need to look up my bike’s problem on YouTube, watch a video, get some tools,
and fix it.” And he would. So if he doesn’t know what needs to be fixed, his question isn’t
genuine. Now if he says, “I know I’ve not taken responsibility for my behavior in the
marriage, and I’ve put it on you instead. I don’t want to do that anymore. I’m going to fix MY
BEHAVIOR. Here are some behaviors you’ve asked me to fix in the past. And I’m wondering
If there are any other behaviors I need to work on as well?

Now, THAT’s a beginning. It doesn’t mean anything yet – but at least he is demonstrating
that he has some self-awareness on his own. This would be like him kicking you for 20
years and then stopping suddenly and saying, “I kick you all the time. I shouldn’t do that. I’m
going to stop. Is there anything else I do that bothers you?”

Here’s the thing, if we answer that question for them, (and we already have for 20 years,
remember?) we don’t give them a chance to show that they understand or have insight or
self-awareness on their own. And if they don’t have it and they are unwilling to search for it
then it doesn’t matter what you tell them. They will do one of two things with the
information you give them.

  1. They will jump through your hoops and make the aesthetic changes “you are
    demanding” (“Oh she’s so demanding. She wants me to stop kicking her in the shins –
    picky, picky woman, but whatever.”) in order to maintain control over you. But it won’t last
    because it isn’t real.
  2. They will turn it back onto you again – and say it’s your problem and your fault – and
    challenge YOU to take responsibility again and “fix it.”

What they will NOT do (generally speaking) is go out on their OWN initiative and get some
therapy and read the books and figure out what they are doing wrong (you’ve told them a
million times, right?) – and work on themselves and their own behavior. They won’t do it
because they can’t. They live in an alternate reality where you are a Lego character in their
universe. You’re not allowed to be YOU. In full color. In flesh and blood with your own
ideas, experiences, perceptions, opinions, etc.

So how do you answer? “I’ve already told you over the course of many years. I’m not going
to insult your intelligence by going over it again. Get therapy. Google. Read books. Get help
for yourself. I’m not taking responsibility for your behavior anymore. Just my own. We are
both grownups now. Let’s both start acting like one.”

I was just talking to Patrick Doyle the other day, and he said, “The salesman’s job starts
when the customer says no.”

Your man is a salesman. And do you know what he’s selling? A seat next to him so he can
keep kicking you in the shins.

Now if you’re kicking yourself right now because you think you’re a fool for staying so long –
DONT. That’s not helpful to you. And that’s not going to give you the motivation, courage,
and self-confidence to get out of that room. Besides, it isn’t YOU that wanted to stay. It was
your brain’s programming. Your brain has been recording all the things you’ve been taking
in through your senses since you were a baby and then your brain took all that data and
turned it into a program, or manual, for your life. Most of your decisions and behavior
throughout your life have been made unconsciously based on your brain’s programming.

Your challenge is to learn how to reveal your programming and then decide whether or not
you like it and want to keep it. This is the work we do in Flying Higher.

So What DO YOU do when your husband says, “How Can I Fix This?”

You let go of your need to control him.

Control his behavior
Control his lack of initiative
Control the way he shows up as a parent

You aren’t his mommy or his fixer-upper or his Holy Spirit. He’s a grown-ass man. If he
wants to figure out how to stop kicking his wife in the shin, he can do it. And if he chooses
not to for whatever reason that’s his choice, and he gets to make it for his life.

You also take back your own control

What you do
What you say
Who you are

How do YOU want to show up for yourself? For your life? Do you want to be in a room with
a shin kicker or are there other options? If so, what are they? Start to explore them. Ask
yourself if you’d like to have a different result in your life.

The last thing you’ll need to do is tolerate the disapproval you’ll get (because these guys
really need a shin to kick) by allowing g uncomfortable feelings. You see, your man isn’t the
only shin kicker in the universe. And when you leave his room, you’ll discover that many
other rooms in your life have a shin kicker in them. You’ll begin to recognize the shin
kickers in time to leave the room before they can kick your shin and you’ll also discover that
some shin kickers are going to chase you down because they really believe that a woman’s
place is in a chair next to a shin kicker.

And when you say “NO,” they are going to be pig-biting mad.

So what are you going to do? Try to make all the shin kickers happy? Or are you going to go
out and live your badass life? I hope it’s the latter.

Thanks for listening, and until next time – fly free.


  1. Avatar

    This is amazing advice Natalie! I wish all counselors were so wise.
    . After I couldn’t take the cruel treatment anymore and said I wanted to separate, my shinkicker “I don’t know what it was I did wrong but I want to make it right”
    Umm repeated controlling, demeaning behavior and dishonesty and you have no idea what you did wrong.

  2. Avatar

    Really appreciated this. Thank you Natalie!
    My shin kicker is winding up with a diatribe on how unforgiving and bitter I am because I have set some boundaries. (Yeah, he gave me a head’s up!) I’m working on a non programmed response. Learning wisdom is sooooo challenging, but THANK YOU for the help!

  3. Avatar

    Ha, I see you know my shin kicker! He once again asked what he could do to change. That opened the door to a 2-hour shin kicking filibuster, always quick to remind me that 90% of our problems are my fault. Little did he know, that after 4 decades of marriage, I was in the final stages of my plan to leave him. One month later I was gone forever.\

    That was nearly 3 years ago. I am now divorced and have assumed my maiden name! Much thanks Natalie for your many brave articles, podcasts and book, very helpful!


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Is It Me?

Is It Me?

Making Sense of Your Confusing Marriage

A Christian woman’s guide to hidden emotional and spiritual abuse.

Learn More

Get the first chapter of my book PLUS the first chapter of the companion workbook FREE when you sign up below!

(Psst...your email is TOTALLY safe with me. Plus you can unsubscribe anytime.)

Is It Me?

Companion Workbook

Guiding and Supporting You Through Each Chapter

Learn More
Is It Me?

The Sisterhood

An online coaching, education, and support community for women of faith in destructive relationships.

Explore the Sisterhood
Is It Me?

Is It Me? Small Groups

Read through Is It Me? with a trained facilitator and other women in a small group.

Join a Group
Is It Me?

Flying Free Podcast

Experts, Survivor Stories, Interviews, and More

Listen Now!

Latest Flying Free Articles

Amazon Affiliate Disclaimer

Flying Free is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.